‘Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has.’ (Margaret Mead) ‘520,000,000,000’. I wrote the number slowly…and…deliberately across the whiteboard at the front of the class. The students looked on, intrigued. I asked, ‘Who can guess what this number means?’ The playful ones quickly put their hands up: ‘The population of the world?’ ‘The distance to the moon?’ I responded, ‘The number of Pesos (= US $8 billion) that people across the world spend on skin-whitening products in one year.’ The room was filled with looks and sounds of astonishment now. The students had considered this as a private personal-relational issue rather than a global economic one. This was part of a 3-day workshop for student teachers and social workers – that is, key influencers for the future – in the Philippines. The first time I had arrived in the country, I had been naively taken aback when one of the people who greeted me apologised for their skin colour. My Filipina co-facilitator explained that this is a common phenomenon, where people evaluate themselves and are evaluated by others for how dark or light their skin is. The students went on to share heart-breaking personal testimonies of how far this has impacted their lives, prospects and sense of worth. They were very surprised to hear how much money, by contrast, people in wealthy countries spend on products, treatments and trips abroad to darken their skin. I took some skin-tanning lotion with me from the UK to show them – and they could hardly believe their eyes. We went on to consider the deep cultural drivers and diverse vested interests that lay behind the skin-whitening industry. The lively debate that ensued generated novel campaign ideas to address stakeholders (e.g. manufacturers; marketers; retailers; consumers), and its damaging spiritual, psychosocial and financial effects.
18 Comments
Femi Williams
15/12/2023 01:46:35 pm
A white guy teaching non-white people about skin colour. That's rich!!
Reply
Nick Wright
15/12/2023 01:52:04 pm
Hi Femi. Yes, it would have been, if I had been there to teach. I co-designed and co-facilitated the workshop with a native Filipina - a grass roots activist who was a source of real insight and inspiration as we worked on this programme together.
Reply
Femi Williams
15/12/2023 01:57:31 pm
Yeah, but you're still white. You don't have the lived experience of non-white people. How can you know what it's like??
Nick Wright
15/12/2023 02:08:43 pm
Hi Femi. Yes, that is true. The value of an 'external' facilitator, alongside an 'internal' one, can be to stimulate a process of what Paulo Freire calls 'conscientisation'. You may be familiar with it?
Errol Johnson
15/12/2023 04:52:38 pm
Femi: Typical white guy using big words to make himself sound impressive.
Nick Wright
15/12/2023 10:11:37 pm
Hi Errol. Paulo Freire was a Brazilian educator and philosopher. He coined the phrase 'conscientisation' in his radical and ground-breaking book, 'Pedagogy of the Oppressed' (1968).
Frank Davies
15/12/2023 01:48:01 pm
Interesting post, Nick. "We went on to consider". How did you do that? Can you say more?
Reply
Nick Wright
15/12/2023 01:55:37 pm
Thank you, Frank. After contracting sensitively with the group to create a safe-enough space for this kind of conversation, we posed a number of questions to stimulate critical reflection in the group. These included:
Reply
Caroline Westman
15/12/2023 01:50:21 pm
Nick, those figures are shocking. I had no idea it was such a huge commercial enterprise. Thanks for bringing this to our attention, although I have no idea what I can do about it. Do you have any ideas? Thanks Nick.
Reply
Nick Wright
15/12/2023 02:03:21 pm
Hi Caroline. To be honest, I hadn't realised either until we began researching for this workshop. I was aware of the skin-whitening phenomenon but hadn't been anywhere near aware enough of its scale and impacts. On taking action, these links may be of interest as a starting point:
Reply
Jon Briggs
15/12/2023 10:29:22 pm
Hey Nick. I see what you mean about spiritual and psychosocial effects. What do you mean by financial effects? Am I missing something?
Reply
Nick Wright
15/12/2023 10:39:12 pm
Hi Jon. That's a good question. The most immediate financial impact is the amount and proportion of a person's income that they spend on skin-whitening products. Broader indirect costs include medical fees and associated costs to treat the damage caused by such products - where the poor have access to such remedies: which is rare.
Reply
Ellie Ryan
15/12/2023 10:40:34 pm
I think I'm naive too, Nick. Why do people use these skin whitening products if they are so dangerous?
Reply
Nick Wright
15/12/2023 10:51:41 pm
Hi Ellie. It's a good and complex question and, to be honest, I'm not qualified to answer. The most common reasons for using them, cited by the Filipinos at the workshop, were to enhance (a) self-worth and (b) social desirability. These reasons revealed deeper cultural beliefs and norms.
Reply
Djemâa Hamida
15/12/2023 11:52:43 pm
Thank you Nick to write this. It touch my heart. When I was child, my parents apologised when they introduced me to the friends. They said sorry for my dark skin. The friends said they felt sorry for my parents. It was terrible. It deep hurt me. I'm happy you write this. Thank you.
Reply
Nick Wright
16/12/2023 11:29:50 am
Hi Djemâa and thank you for sharing from personal experience. I can only imagine how painful those experiences must have been for you. I remember speaking with a Tunisian student who described, in tears, very similar experiences in her life too.
Reply
Funmi Johnson
16/12/2023 01:49:00 pm
Wow! I knew it was a lot but I didn’t know it was that much. There’s so much unpacking to do around race, colourism, classism and the intersectionalities that play out.
Reply
Nick Wright
16/12/2023 07:25:40 pm
Hi Funmi. And the projections are for far, far higher revenues for those invested in the skin-whitening industry. I agree, the underlying issues and drivers for those who buy and use such products are deep and complex. 🥹
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Nick WrightI'm a psychological coach, trainer and OD consultant. Curious to discover how can I help you? Get in touch! Like what you read? Simply enter your email address below to receive regular blog updates!
|